Förintelseförnekarna påstår att krematoriet i Auschwitz huvudläger (Stammlager) aldrig kan ha fungerat, att byggnaden är en bluff, för skorstenen sitter inte ihop med byggnaden. De försöker göra en sak av detta, hånar och tramsar, och menar att detta skulle vara ett bevis för att förintelsen skulle vara en bluff.
I länken så kan ni se bilderna på skorstenen och vad förnekarna påstår om det, samt förklaringarna varför förnekarna som vanligt har fel och avslöjas som okunniga eller helt enkelt ljuga.
Jag citerar lite av texten här, för att se bilderna så klicka på länken och läs mer.
Källa: http://holocaustcontroversies.blogsp...l#kremachimney Blå text i länken är klickbar till mer info
Varför gör förnekarna såhär? Bevisligen kan ju skorstenar funka utan att de måste vara ihopbyggda rent fysiskt med byggnaden de hör till, det finns många exempel på skorstenar som är anslutna via kulvertar.
Och i fallet ovan så finns ju flertalet originalritningar där man kan se hur skorstenen var kopplad till krematoriet via kulvertar.
Som jag ser det så är detta ännu ett exempel på hur oseriösa förnekarna är.
I länken så kan ni se bilderna på skorstenen och vad förnekarna påstår om det, samt förklaringarna varför förnekarna som vanligt har fel och avslöjas som okunniga eller helt enkelt ljuga.
Jag citerar lite av texten här, för att se bilderna så klicka på länken och läs mer.
Källa: http://holocaustcontroversies.blogsp...l#kremachimney Blå text i länken är klickbar till mer info
Citat:
Short debunking: this is the crematorium 1 in the so-called main camp; during the war the crematorium (including the morgue that served as a gas chamber) was converted into an air-raid shelter; after the war it was restored by the authorities to represent the original state, including the chimney. The attempt was partially symbolic and partially botched. That said, the chimney always looked "detached" because it was connected to the crematorium by underground flues.
Further comments: it is not clear what the argument is supposed to prove. That there was no crematorium there? This is debunked by numerous documents acknowledged by all leading deniers. No leading denier denies that the crematorium with a functioning chimney actually existed there during the war. They only deny its homicidal function. So this meme is doubly deceptive because it goes even against the leading deniers, not to mention proven history. The author of the meme acts as if they're the first person ever to have noticed that the chimney is detached. This sort of argumentation may work on simple, naive rubes but not on someone willing to do some basic research.
Pressac explains about the chimneys of the crematorium before the conversion into an air-raid shelter: "[t]he initial chimney was of circular section, but as the result of damage it was replaced by one of square section. ... Between the furnace room and the chimney there was a shed housing the motor for the collective forced draught installation for the three furnaces" (Auschwitz: Technique and operation of the gas chambers, p. 131).
That is, the chimneys - the unreconstructed ones - had always looked "detached", especially the second one. Because they were connected to the crematorium by the underground flues. (This was due to the standard cremation oven design which allowed for (optional) recuperation of heat of the combustion gases, which were sucked out of the incineration muffle in the downward direction due to chimney draft while giving off the heat to the neighboring ducts with the combustion air streaming upwards, into the incineration chamber.)
Here's a German wartime plan of the crematorium (dated 03.08.1942) showing both chimneys: the old one (the taller one) and the new one (doc. 8 in Pressac, Die Krematorien von Auschwitz):
Numerous plans show the "detached" chimney and the underground flues, like this one from 25.09.1941:
As a side note: there were relatively few gassings in Auschwitz I as opposed to Birkenau (Auschwitz II), it is unlikely that the number of the people gassed in this small gas chamber exceeded 10000, so the "non-stop" comment, if it has ever been uttered, must have referred to the Birkenau crematoria, not to this Krema that played a truly secondary role in the Auschwitz Holocaust.
Further reading: Pressac's Auschwitz: Technique and operation of the gas chambers, pp. 132, 133.
Further comments: it is not clear what the argument is supposed to prove. That there was no crematorium there? This is debunked by numerous documents acknowledged by all leading deniers. No leading denier denies that the crematorium with a functioning chimney actually existed there during the war. They only deny its homicidal function. So this meme is doubly deceptive because it goes even against the leading deniers, not to mention proven history. The author of the meme acts as if they're the first person ever to have noticed that the chimney is detached. This sort of argumentation may work on simple, naive rubes but not on someone willing to do some basic research.
Pressac explains about the chimneys of the crematorium before the conversion into an air-raid shelter: "[t]he initial chimney was of circular section, but as the result of damage it was replaced by one of square section. ... Between the furnace room and the chimney there was a shed housing the motor for the collective forced draught installation for the three furnaces" (Auschwitz: Technique and operation of the gas chambers, p. 131).
That is, the chimneys - the unreconstructed ones - had always looked "detached", especially the second one. Because they were connected to the crematorium by the underground flues. (This was due to the standard cremation oven design which allowed for (optional) recuperation of heat of the combustion gases, which were sucked out of the incineration muffle in the downward direction due to chimney draft while giving off the heat to the neighboring ducts with the combustion air streaming upwards, into the incineration chamber.)
Here's a German wartime plan of the crematorium (dated 03.08.1942) showing both chimneys: the old one (the taller one) and the new one (doc. 8 in Pressac, Die Krematorien von Auschwitz):
Numerous plans show the "detached" chimney and the underground flues, like this one from 25.09.1941:
As a side note: there were relatively few gassings in Auschwitz I as opposed to Birkenau (Auschwitz II), it is unlikely that the number of the people gassed in this small gas chamber exceeded 10000, so the "non-stop" comment, if it has ever been uttered, must have referred to the Birkenau crematoria, not to this Krema that played a truly secondary role in the Auschwitz Holocaust.
Further reading: Pressac's Auschwitz: Technique and operation of the gas chambers, pp. 132, 133.
Varför gör förnekarna såhär? Bevisligen kan ju skorstenar funka utan att de måste vara ihopbyggda rent fysiskt med byggnaden de hör till, det finns många exempel på skorstenar som är anslutna via kulvertar.
Och i fallet ovan så finns ju flertalet originalritningar där man kan se hur skorstenen var kopplad till krematoriet via kulvertar.
Som jag ser det så är detta ännu ett exempel på hur oseriösa förnekarna är.
