Det är snarare så att det resultatet har man bara sett i en enda studie, och det var en studie där mätmetoderna sannolikt var felaktiga.
Citat:
There is disagreement as to whether amino acid feeding before or after resistance exercise promotes MPS to a greater extent. It has been reported that ingestion of essential amino acids taken with a carbohydrate supplement immediately before resistance exercise resulted in greater leg uptake of amino acids, but the results are quantitatively difficult to believe, given that they were made under non-steady-state conditions, and the increases in uptake were physiologically unlikely to represent increases in MPS, given their size (20-fold!), but, more likely, some artifact, such as pooling of amino acids within muscle. Furthermore, it has been recently shown by direct measurement of FSR in humans that feeding 1 h before an acute bout of high-intensity resistance exercise did not further enhance MPS during the 2-h postexercise period. Thus, once again, the leg tracer dilution method appears to yield qualitatively and quantitatively different results to those obtained by incorporation of tracer amino acids.
http://jap.physiology.org/cgi/content/full/106/6/2026
Före-intag finns det alltså ingen speciell evidens för. Alla studier som gjorts har däremot visat effekten av efter-intag.
Skall också tilläggas att EAA-intag eller proteindrinkar i samband med träning kanske inte har någon som helst effekt på muskeltillväxten överhuvudtaget, jämfört med att äta samma totala mängd protein från vanlig mat, och inte ens med något intag i direkt anslutning till träning.