2008-12-01, 15:26
#49
FritzDaCat:
David Coles hemsida på .vho.org säger så här om varför Krema I övergavs som gaskammare:
Är det Dr Piper som har fel, alltså?
En ciceron – Alicia – menar också att Krema I övergavs som gaskammare för att den låg för nära the inmates (”too close to the inmates”), inte SS-männens egna lokaler(FritzDaCat ovan) :
Cole tycker det låter konstigt, om tittar på kartan:
Här nämndes alltså SS-männens lokaler, som FritzDaCat ansåg hotade av gasen:
Zyklon B spreds över stora områden?
Å andra sidan låg den bra till som skyddsrum för SS personalen (vilket den var när ryssarna kom dit).
Gaskammarn i Auschwitz-Birkenau verkar vara öppen för insyn, däremot!!! :
Citat:
Anledningen till att man upprättade nya krematorier var inte att 'Krema I var för synlig'. Det gjordes av praktiska skäl för att man behövde en större anläggning (Auschwitz-Birkenau). Dessutom låg Krema I väldigt nära SS-männens egna lokaler, så de kan ha tyckt att det var farligt för dem själva.
David Coles hemsida på .vho.org säger så här om varför Krema I övergavs som gaskammare:
Citat:
To get to the truth of this matter, there are some other pertinent questions that can be asked. If there was at one time a functioning gas chamber in this building, why was its operation halted, especially if the Nazis were running Auschwitz as an extermination center?
Well, Dr. Piper has an answer for that one, too. In an essay published in the Polish book Auschwitz, Piper writes that exterminations were moved to new gas chambers in the Auschwitz-Birkenau complex because it had become too difficult to keep the gas chamber at the Auschwitz main camp a secret from the inmates.
Well, Dr. Piper has an answer for that one, too. In an essay published in the Polish book Auschwitz, Piper writes that exterminations were moved to new gas chambers in the Auschwitz-Birkenau complex because it had become too difficult to keep the gas chamber at the Auschwitz main camp a secret from the inmates.
Är det Dr Piper som har fel, alltså?
En ciceron – Alicia – menar också att Krema I övergavs som gaskammare för att den låg för nära the inmates (”too close to the inmates”), inte SS-männens egna lokaler(FritzDaCat ovan) :
Citat:
This has apparently become part of official Auschwitz lore because it is something Alicia repeated to me on the tour.
Alicia: In spite of this [the] crematorium was next to the block where prisoners lived. That's right, extermination was moved to Birkenau. That's why four crematoriums with gas chambers were built in Birkenau.
Now, let's be perfectly clear about this. They say that exterminations were moved to Birkenau because the gas chamber at the main camp was too close to the inmates and therefore they could know what was going on.
Alicia: In spite of this [the] crematorium was next to the block where prisoners lived. That's right, extermination was moved to Birkenau. That's why four crematoriums with gas chambers were built in Birkenau.
Now, let's be perfectly clear about this. They say that exterminations were moved to Birkenau because the gas chamber at the main camp was too close to the inmates and therefore they could know what was going on.
Cole tycker det låter konstigt, om tittar på kartan:
Citat:
But is this even remotely accurate? Let's refer back to our map of the main camp. Now here's the gas chamber right there, and there's the rows of inmates barracks. As you can see, the gas chamber is well outside the prison compound. It's hidden from view by the three SS building which effectively hide it from the inmates' sight.
Plus we're told, the arrivals who are going to be gassed would be taken in through here, thus avoiding any and all contact with the other inmates. This was a gas chamber that could functioned completely isolated from anybody's notice.
Plus we're told, the arrivals who are going to be gassed would be taken in through here, thus avoiding any and all contact with the other inmates. This was a gas chamber that could functioned completely isolated from anybody's notice.
Här nämndes alltså SS-männens lokaler, som FritzDaCat ansåg hotade av gasen:
Citat:
Dessutom låg Krema I väldigt nära SS-männens egna lokaler, så de kan ha tyckt att det var farligt för dem själva.
Zyklon B spreds över stora områden?
Å andra sidan låg den bra till som skyddsrum för SS personalen (vilket den var när ryssarna kom dit).
Gaskammarn i Auschwitz-Birkenau verkar vara öppen för insyn, däremot!!! :
Citat:
Now this is Auschwitz-Birkenau in an Allied arial photo from September 1944. These are the two crematoriums and " gas chambers," with the crematoriums above ground and L-shaped below ground rooms that were either gas chambers or mortuaries. And here you have the rows and rows of inmates barracks.
Now the thing that becomes immediately clear is there is nothing but a barbed wire fence hiding the inmates' barracks from the gas chambers.
And this over here was the Auschwitz [Birkenau] sports field, right next door to the "gas chambers." And another thing to notice is not only could you see the "gas chamber," paralled with the barracks, but you could see diagonally to the one across the way from you. Nothing was hidden from the inmates.
http://www.vho.org/GB/c/DC/gcgvcole.html
Now the thing that becomes immediately clear is there is nothing but a barbed wire fence hiding the inmates' barracks from the gas chambers.
And this over here was the Auschwitz [Birkenau] sports field, right next door to the "gas chambers." And another thing to notice is not only could you see the "gas chamber," paralled with the barracks, but you could see diagonally to the one across the way from you. Nothing was hidden from the inmates.
http://www.vho.org/GB/c/DC/gcgvcole.html
