Varför hade så många fel om AI? Intressant artikel om hur "experter" försökte pricka in när AI skulle klara matte, fysik osv. vs när det faktiskt hände.
Citat:
Superforecasters look worst; AI company CEOs look prescient but optimistic
Superforecasters have consistently expected slower progress than everyone else, so collectively have the worst track record.
This is clearly shown in the recent LEAP panel, but goes back to at least 2022, when superforecasters predicted compute used on the largest AI experiment would be $35m by 2024 and $100m by 2030, when in fact it was already likely over $100m by 2024, four years earlier.
Why did the best forecasters do so badly? I’d speculate it’s because the best way to predict short-term geopolitical events is to assume things will stay the same, or at least remain on trend, while AI is highly trend-breaking.
An incorrect implication of all this is that “expert views are useless”. Experts in AI were better at forecasting progress than the general public. And the main way experts have been wrong is not expecting progress to be even faster. In other words, they’ve been underhyping AI, rather than hyping it.
The AI company leaders, the people most accused of hype, are among the few who’ve erred optimistic. We don’t have many quantified predictions, but the ones that have resolved mostly came true, just sometimes later than suggested. Here are the ones I could find:
Jan 2025: Altman said agents would join the workforce in 2025. They trickled in but took off in early 2026.
Jun 2025: Altman said 2026 will see AI that can have novel insights (correct)
Oct 2025: Altman said an intern-level automated AI researcher would arrive by Sept 2026. OpenAI says it landed Sept 2026 (self-graded, but seems close)
Mar 2025: Dario said AI would write 90% of code in 3–6 months. Anthropic’s own codebase hit 80% after 14 months (too optimistic).
https://benjamintodd.substack.com/p/almost-every-ai-forecast-of-the-last
Citat:
OpenAI has announced three major scientific breakthroughs, spanning mathematics, computer science, and theoretical physics.
Mathematics: A proof of the local smoothing conjecture in all dimensions, which also resolves the Kakeya and Stein restriction conjectures.
Computer science: A disproof of the Exponential Time Hypothesis, a long-standing assumption about the computational difficulty of certain problems.
Physics: Rigorous existence proofs for quantum field theories, including QCD, alongside a completion of the Standard Model. The announcement addresses Yang–Mills existence but does not claim to solve the full Millennium Prize problem.
https://openai.com/index/building-scientific-understanding-with-academic-communities/
Citat:
Ursprungligen postat av
RandomNPC
Visst, den emulerade intelligensen bildar ny kunskap ur information utan kreativitet vilket inte ger ett originellt nytillskott till världen. Det är endast interpolation i den befintliga informationsrymden. En mänsklig uppfinnare däremot kan extrapolera ur denna information och ge oss originell kunskap.
Det en vanlig människa gör en åtta timmars arbetsdag går att bryta ner till en massa mindre delmoment. Nästan allt går att göra med AI nu. Tror du kreativitet kommer förbi mänskligt? Det går att plocka isär och göra syntetiskt. Jag ser folk tabba ut ur Chat så fort jag öppnar dörren på vårt kontor...Vi är långt förbi den enkla llm-eran (2018-2020) med stokastiska papegojor. Dagens system använder llm som en kärna som gallrar och rensar sökrymden, intuitions-moduler för våra datorer. Datorer brukade vara dumma men nu är dom smarta. En modern AI är som en symfoniorkester med AI agenter med lång och korttids-minne, återkoppling, verifiering, evolutionära algoritmer. Och då är vi idag på MS-DOS nivå av AI, mycket mer kommer snart.