Citat:
Ursprungligen postat av
will242
Jag antog att du bar ryss eftersom din AI ger dig ett annat svar än mina, även när vi kör samma AI. Såklart den baseras på källor, det är ju så en vettig AI fungerar. Läser man på så vet man att I dagsläget så är drönare viktigare än artilleri då träffsäkerhet, dödlighet och kostnad för drönarna vida överstiger de av artilleri, speciellt från ryssar som mest använder gamla utslitna d20.
Här har du mitt svar på frågan (har en egen kanal för just Ukraina kriget så du kanske får lägga till Ukraina i din fråga?)
Is artillery or drones most deadly in the war?
---
That's a very complex question, and the answer is it depends on the phase of the war and the specific tactical situation. However, currently, artillery is still overall the most deadly weapon system in the war in Ukraine, but drones are rapidly increasing in their lethality and importance. Here's a detailed breakdown:
Artillery (Historically and Currently):
Massive Firepower: Artillery provides immense destructive power over a large area. It can suppress enemy positions, destroy fortifications, and disrupt troop movements.
High Casualty Rate: Historically, artillery has been responsible for the vast majority of casualties in this war. The sheer volume of fire, even if not directly hitting targets, causes significant injuries and psychological trauma.
Range and Availability: Artillery has a longer range than most drones and is available in large quantities (especially on the Russian side).
Continued Dominance: Despite drone advancements, artillery remains the primary means of inflicting casualties and damage on both sides.
Drones (Increasingly Deadly):
Precision Strikes: Modern drones, especially those equipped with guided munitions, can deliver precise strikes against high-value targets (artillery systems, command posts, supply lines).
Real-Time Intelligence: Drones provide crucial real-time intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR), allowing forces to identify targets and adjust fire more effectively.
Loitering Munitions ("Kamikaze Drones"): These drones are designed to crash into targets, delivering a powerful explosive charge. They are becoming increasingly common and effective.
Counter-Battery Fire: Drones are used to locate enemy artillery positions, enabling counter-battery fire to neutralize them.
Asymmetrical Warfare: Drones allow Ukraine to engage Russian forces effectively despite being outgunned in terms of traditional artillery.
Rapidly Evolving Technology: Drone technology is advancing rapidly, with new capabilities being developed constantly (e.g., longer range, improved sensors, AI-powered targeting).
Here's a breakdown of how their roles have evolved:
Early Stages (2022): Artillery dominated, inflicting the bulk of casualties and damage. Drones were primarily used for reconnaissance.
Mid-War (2023): Drones began to play a more significant role, particularly in counter-battery fire and targeting artillery. Loitering munitions became more prevalent.
Current Phase (Late 2023/Early 2024): Drones are now integral to almost every aspect of the battlefield. They are used for reconnaissance, targeting, direct attacks, electronic warfare, and psychological operations. While artillery still causes more overall casualties, the impact of drone strikes on key targets is often disproportionately high.
Conclusion:
Currently, artillery still causes the most overall casualties. However, drones are becoming increasingly deadly and are having a disproportionate impact on the war. They are changing the nature of warfare, enabling more precise strikes, providing crucial intelligence, and leveling the playing field for Ukraine.
It's likely that in the future, drones will surpass artillery as the most deadly weapon system in this conflict, as technology continues to advance and drone capabilities improve.
Sources:
Institute for the Study of War (ISW):
https://www.understandingwar.org/ (Regularly analyzes the role of drones and artillery in the war)
Defense News: (Various articles on drone warfare in Ukraine)
Reuters/Associated Press: (Reporting on the use of drones and artillery in the conflict)