Kritiken mot Rind studien var felaktig och många av kritikerna gjorde grova felaktigheter. Rind och co. har redan svarat på kritiken och visat dess felaktigheter.
http://home.wanadoo.nl/ipce/library_two/rbt/condemn_frame.htm Börja här.
"The Leadership Council
In its press release attacking our study (May 24, 1999), the Leadership Council claimed that its "membership includes many of the nation's most prominent mental health leaders," with a mission "to insure the public receives accurate information about mental health issues." It noted the ethical duty of researchers to report research "in accordance with recognized standards of scientific competence and to minimize the possibility that results will be misleading." In his correspondence with the APA (June 3, 1999), Fink noted that his organization was concerned about a "misuse of the media ... and the use of sound bytes [sic] rather than real science." He noted that they "are committed to a high level of scientific discourse."
Given this self-characterization, one might expect that the Leadership Council's criticisms would be sound, competent, and not misleading; the organization would avoid providing sound bites of its own to the media; and it would not assist a governmental body in undermining a rigorously peer-reviewed article in a premiere scientific journal. Such goals could be achieved by submitting a
[page 46]
critique to a journal for peer-review and publication, allowing us to respond so that interested researchers could draw their own conclusions. Instead, their criticisms were flawed and misleading; they provided sound bites to media critics eager to attack our study; and they offered non-peer reviewed criticisms to Congress as if they were established fact. Science was ill-served.
The Leadership Council presents itself as a group of prominent mental health leaders, implying that its views are authoritative and representative of the field. However, its membership largely represents an extremely controversial segment of the mental health field, whose views are not widely accepted as valid, particularly among academic researchers. Its membership consists of predominantly psychoanalytically -- or psychodynamically -- oriented pratitioners or advocates, who appear to accept repressed memories as undisputed fact and believe in recovered memory therapy as well as the validity of MPD.
Fink's correspondence with the APA (June 3, 1999) regarding the background and scientific basis of the Leadership Council's work makes the group's goals clear. Fink complained about the "destructive theories that justify a trivialization of sexual abuse" and an "effort to reduce and destroy psychotherapy by undermining some of the basic principles" by which they conduct their work. He noted that his group was committed to a reversal of trends in which the courts and media were defending those "who would impugn all of psychiatry" because of personal distress. Additionally, he noted that his group wanted to "protect GOOD psychotherapists from attack and from financial ruin as a result of suits that are costly both financially and emotionally" (capitalization in the original).
Recovered memory therapists, enjoying widespread acceptance in the late 1980s and early 1990s, have more recently been on the defensive. Early on, recovered memories formed the basis for thousands of suits against alleged perpetrators (e.g., fathers) of CSA and often SRA as well. But then former patients began retracting these memories, holding their therapists responsible for implantation of false memories and subsequent injury to them and their families, and then suing their therapists for damages. As Fink indicated in his correspondence with the APA, these suits substantially con-
[page 47]
cern his group. Some of his group's members have been subjected to such suits.
Ubiquitous and severe harm is a premise that underlies belief in widespread repression of memories of CSA and in the occurrence of MPD. A challenge to this premise adds to the growing trend questioning the validity of these therapeutic beliefs. As such, the Leadership Council might be expected to challenge a study such as ours. The problem from our view is not the challenge itself, but the manner in which it was conducted. Peer-review of criticisms in scientific forums reduces bias or misrepresentation by not accepting such criticisms for publication, or by publishing them but permitting those challenged to respond. Circumventing scientific protocol by providing one-sided and severely flawed critiques to conservative social commentators and political entities, however, is a challenge that is destructive to science,
The following example shows clearly the Leadership Council's commitment to advocacy rather than scientific accuracy.
As discussed previously, day care sexual and satanic abuse cases have now been all but discredited. In the original case (the McMartin preschool in California) in 1984, hundreds of children were interviewed by social workers, resulting in accusations of being sexually assaulted in hot-air balloons, faraway farms, the shoulders of busy highways, cemeteries, and tunnels under the schoolyard; witnessing animals being tortured and ritually sacrificed and staff rnembers dressing up as witches and flying in the air; and being forced to drink the blood of a baby who had just been murdered.
These accusations were almost certainly all false, the result of coercive interrogations premised on faulty assumptions about CSA effects on mental health and memory (Ceci & Bruck, 1993; Garven et al., 1998; Nathan, 1990; Nathan & Snedeker, 1995).
Later that year in Malden, Massachusetts a similar case occurred at the Fells Acres day care center. One prosecutor flew to California to consult with the McMartin trial team. The Fells Acres children's allegations subsequently took on many of the same ritualistic and bizarre aspects as the McMartin case, Under interrogation by a pediatric nurse committed to belief in SRA, the children complained of such things as being sadistically molested in "secret" or "magic" rooms by clowns and lobsters, assaulted with a
[page 48]
butcher knife, stomped on by elephants, threatened by robots if they disclosed the abuse, and exposed to a dog being killed and buried. The Amiraults -- a mother and her adult son and daughter who ran the center-were convicted and sentenced to lengthy prison terms (Harris, 1995; Pendergrast, 1996).
In this case, the mother and daughter spent a decade in prison until a judge ordered a new trial for them based on a technicality in 1995. The mother died of cancer soon afterwards. In 1998, another judge dismissed all charges against the daughter, ruling that the children in the case had been so manipulated in interviews that their testimony was forever tainted. To illustrate, the judge read a transcript showing how investigators insistently refused to take "no" for an answer to questions about abuse (New York Tmes, June 13, 1998, A6). The judge was influenced by the new thinking on children's suggestibility, which resulted from the empirical research of Ceci and others, which had already played a key role in causing similar cases around the country to fall apart in the 1990s. In 1999, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts ruled on whether to reinstate the conviction.
The Leadership Council submitted an amicus curiae brief, that stated:
It is the position of the undersigned, as an organization comprised of well-respected, oft-published, eminent professionals in the field of psychiatry and developmental science with regard to trauma including child sexual abuse. that no new evidence has emerged in the area of suggestibility with respect to preschool-aged victims of child sexual abuse since the trial in this matter.
Thus, incredibly, the Leadership Council maintained that between 1987 and 1999 no relevant research on CSA and suggestibility had been conducted. This remarkable position reflects strong advocacy rather than dispassionate science, and perhaps gives some context to the Leadership Council's seriously flawed critique of our re"ew.
The Supreme Judicial Court reinstated the conviction, ruling that the law was properly carried out in the 1987 trial. A vice president of the Leadership Council reacted by commenting to the media, .'Stick a fork in them. They're done" (Boston Herald. August 19, 1999, p. 5). The Amiraults are most likely completely innocent,
[page 49]
given the striking similarity between their case and the discredited ones all around the country (Rosenthal, 1999). As such, it does not appear that "justice" (part of the Leadership Council's full title) was well served."
http://home.wanadoo.nl/ipce/library_two/rbt/condemn_frame.htm Börja här.
"The Leadership Council
In its press release attacking our study (May 24, 1999), the Leadership Council claimed that its "membership includes many of the nation's most prominent mental health leaders," with a mission "to insure the public receives accurate information about mental health issues." It noted the ethical duty of researchers to report research "in accordance with recognized standards of scientific competence and to minimize the possibility that results will be misleading." In his correspondence with the APA (June 3, 1999), Fink noted that his organization was concerned about a "misuse of the media ... and the use of sound bytes [sic] rather than real science." He noted that they "are committed to a high level of scientific discourse."
Given this self-characterization, one might expect that the Leadership Council's criticisms would be sound, competent, and not misleading; the organization would avoid providing sound bites of its own to the media; and it would not assist a governmental body in undermining a rigorously peer-reviewed article in a premiere scientific journal. Such goals could be achieved by submitting a
[page 46]
critique to a journal for peer-review and publication, allowing us to respond so that interested researchers could draw their own conclusions. Instead, their criticisms were flawed and misleading; they provided sound bites to media critics eager to attack our study; and they offered non-peer reviewed criticisms to Congress as if they were established fact. Science was ill-served.
The Leadership Council presents itself as a group of prominent mental health leaders, implying that its views are authoritative and representative of the field. However, its membership largely represents an extremely controversial segment of the mental health field, whose views are not widely accepted as valid, particularly among academic researchers. Its membership consists of predominantly psychoanalytically -- or psychodynamically -- oriented pratitioners or advocates, who appear to accept repressed memories as undisputed fact and believe in recovered memory therapy as well as the validity of MPD.
Fink's correspondence with the APA (June 3, 1999) regarding the background and scientific basis of the Leadership Council's work makes the group's goals clear. Fink complained about the "destructive theories that justify a trivialization of sexual abuse" and an "effort to reduce and destroy psychotherapy by undermining some of the basic principles" by which they conduct their work. He noted that his group was committed to a reversal of trends in which the courts and media were defending those "who would impugn all of psychiatry" because of personal distress. Additionally, he noted that his group wanted to "protect GOOD psychotherapists from attack and from financial ruin as a result of suits that are costly both financially and emotionally" (capitalization in the original).
Recovered memory therapists, enjoying widespread acceptance in the late 1980s and early 1990s, have more recently been on the defensive. Early on, recovered memories formed the basis for thousands of suits against alleged perpetrators (e.g., fathers) of CSA and often SRA as well. But then former patients began retracting these memories, holding their therapists responsible for implantation of false memories and subsequent injury to them and their families, and then suing their therapists for damages. As Fink indicated in his correspondence with the APA, these suits substantially con-
[page 47]
cern his group. Some of his group's members have been subjected to such suits.
Ubiquitous and severe harm is a premise that underlies belief in widespread repression of memories of CSA and in the occurrence of MPD. A challenge to this premise adds to the growing trend questioning the validity of these therapeutic beliefs. As such, the Leadership Council might be expected to challenge a study such as ours. The problem from our view is not the challenge itself, but the manner in which it was conducted. Peer-review of criticisms in scientific forums reduces bias or misrepresentation by not accepting such criticisms for publication, or by publishing them but permitting those challenged to respond. Circumventing scientific protocol by providing one-sided and severely flawed critiques to conservative social commentators and political entities, however, is a challenge that is destructive to science,
The following example shows clearly the Leadership Council's commitment to advocacy rather than scientific accuracy.
As discussed previously, day care sexual and satanic abuse cases have now been all but discredited. In the original case (the McMartin preschool in California) in 1984, hundreds of children were interviewed by social workers, resulting in accusations of being sexually assaulted in hot-air balloons, faraway farms, the shoulders of busy highways, cemeteries, and tunnels under the schoolyard; witnessing animals being tortured and ritually sacrificed and staff rnembers dressing up as witches and flying in the air; and being forced to drink the blood of a baby who had just been murdered.
These accusations were almost certainly all false, the result of coercive interrogations premised on faulty assumptions about CSA effects on mental health and memory (Ceci & Bruck, 1993; Garven et al., 1998; Nathan, 1990; Nathan & Snedeker, 1995).
Later that year in Malden, Massachusetts a similar case occurred at the Fells Acres day care center. One prosecutor flew to California to consult with the McMartin trial team. The Fells Acres children's allegations subsequently took on many of the same ritualistic and bizarre aspects as the McMartin case, Under interrogation by a pediatric nurse committed to belief in SRA, the children complained of such things as being sadistically molested in "secret" or "magic" rooms by clowns and lobsters, assaulted with a
[page 48]
butcher knife, stomped on by elephants, threatened by robots if they disclosed the abuse, and exposed to a dog being killed and buried. The Amiraults -- a mother and her adult son and daughter who ran the center-were convicted and sentenced to lengthy prison terms (Harris, 1995; Pendergrast, 1996).
In this case, the mother and daughter spent a decade in prison until a judge ordered a new trial for them based on a technicality in 1995. The mother died of cancer soon afterwards. In 1998, another judge dismissed all charges against the daughter, ruling that the children in the case had been so manipulated in interviews that their testimony was forever tainted. To illustrate, the judge read a transcript showing how investigators insistently refused to take "no" for an answer to questions about abuse (New York Tmes, June 13, 1998, A6). The judge was influenced by the new thinking on children's suggestibility, which resulted from the empirical research of Ceci and others, which had already played a key role in causing similar cases around the country to fall apart in the 1990s. In 1999, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts ruled on whether to reinstate the conviction.
The Leadership Council submitted an amicus curiae brief, that stated:
It is the position of the undersigned, as an organization comprised of well-respected, oft-published, eminent professionals in the field of psychiatry and developmental science with regard to trauma including child sexual abuse. that no new evidence has emerged in the area of suggestibility with respect to preschool-aged victims of child sexual abuse since the trial in this matter.
Thus, incredibly, the Leadership Council maintained that between 1987 and 1999 no relevant research on CSA and suggestibility had been conducted. This remarkable position reflects strong advocacy rather than dispassionate science, and perhaps gives some context to the Leadership Council's seriously flawed critique of our re"ew.
The Supreme Judicial Court reinstated the conviction, ruling that the law was properly carried out in the 1987 trial. A vice president of the Leadership Council reacted by commenting to the media, .'Stick a fork in them. They're done" (Boston Herald. August 19, 1999, p. 5). The Amiraults are most likely completely innocent,
[page 49]
given the striking similarity between their case and the discredited ones all around the country (Rosenthal, 1999). As such, it does not appear that "justice" (part of the Leadership Council's full title) was well served."