2012-06-23, 20:32
#121
Citat:
Texten är skriven på djurhud och har återanvänts många gånger. Man håller på att undersöka, med hjälp av rättsmedicinska metoder, vad som stod nedtecknat i de nu "utsuddade" texterna. Man tror att de tidigaste av dessa texter kan dateras och härledas till Muhammeds egna kompanjoner!!
Svar: Detta var så man gjorde läs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parchment,
Citat:
Main article: Palimpsest Reuse
During the seventh through the ninth centuries, many earlier parchment manuscripts were scrubbed and scoured to be ready for rewriting, and often the earlier writing can still be read. These recycled parchments are called palimpsests. Later, more thorough techniques of scouring the surface irretrievably lost the earlier text .
During the seventh through the ninth centuries, many earlier parchment manuscripts were scrubbed and scoured to be ready for rewriting, and often the earlier writing can still be read. These recycled parchments are called palimpsests. Later, more thorough techniques of scouring the surface irretrievably lost the earlier text .
Citat:
“For historical reasons, however, what is of greater interest is the probability that the parchment is older than a certain date. … The probability that the parchment is older than AD 646 is 75.1 %, or a three-to-one likelihood. It is highly probable therefore, that the Ṣanʿāʾ I manuscript was produced no more than 15 years after the death of the Prophet Muhammad.”[43] He concluded that the scriptio inferior text belonged to the period of the companions of Prophet Muhammad, whilst the scriptio superior text belonged to the ʿUthmānic tradition, and using stemmatics, the ʿUthmānic tradition was shown to give the most accurate reproduction of the Prophetic prototype.[44], alltså så skrevs den innan Uthman.
Sen så tar du en quote som jag hittade i en anti islam sida och är en mans åsikt, Det du inte verkar fatta är att uthman inte ändrade koranen på något sätt utom kompilerade den och lät den kontrolleras en massa gånger av bla profetens fruar tills den till slut godkändes och delades ut för att förhindra korruption av koranen då folk hade olika stilar läs http://www.albalagh.net/kids/history...pilation.shtml http://www.islamicwritings.org/quran...-of-the-quran/
Citat:
he compiled Qur’an was kept by Abu Bakr (ra) until he died, then by Umar bin Khattab (ra), and when he died he gave it to his daughter Hafsa (ra). Various Companions such as Abdullah ibn Masud, Ubay bin Ka’b and Ibn Abbas (ra) had their own Masahif (collected pages).
During the Khilafah of Uthman (ra) differences in reading the Qur’an became Obvious and after consultation with the companions, Uthman had a standard copy prepared by Zaid bin Thabit, Abdullah bin Zubair, Said bin Al Asn and Abdur-Rahman bin Harith bin Hisham. Copies were made and distributed. Two of these copies today can be found in Topkapi museum in Istanbul and Tashkent.
During the Khilafah of Uthman (ra) differences in reading the Qur’an became Obvious and after consultation with the companions, Uthman had a standard copy prepared by Zaid bin Thabit, Abdullah bin Zubair, Said bin Al Asn and Abdur-Rahman bin Harith bin Hisham. Copies were made and distributed. Two of these copies today can be found in Topkapi museum in Istanbul and Tashkent.
__________________
Senast redigerad av whoisi 2012-06-23 kl. 20:34.
Senast redigerad av whoisi 2012-06-23 kl. 20:34.
Islam är ju nu inne i sin egen period av "inkvisition".
