2008-02-09, 13:27
#1189
Citat:
Ursprungligen postat av Katalysator
Är det inte jobbigt att vara vapendragare för gamla lögner? Ständigt måste ni göra våld på er egen logik för att inte motsäga 60+ år gammal propaganda. Jag är glad att jag slipper det.
"Bilderna kommer från Treblinka." skriver du. Jaha, skriver jag. Det är ju inte poängen, utan bara ditt försök att blanda bort korten. Var är grävmaskinerna? Var är hålet? Inte i Treblinka i alla fall, för på bilderna därifrån syns varken grävmaskiner eller hål.
"Bilderna kommer från Treblinka." skriver du. Jaha, skriver jag. Det är ju inte poängen, utan bara ditt försök att blanda bort korten. Var är grävmaskinerna? Var är hålet? Inte i Treblinka i alla fall, för på bilderna därifrån syns varken grävmaskiner eller hål.
Ja, det måste vara jobbigt för dem. Förmodligen därför de så tydligt visar att de inte vill ha en hövlig och lugn diskussion om sakfrågorna, utan hellre tramsa och ösa tillmälen över alla som vågar tvivla offentligt och anonymt på detta ställe, så vitt jag känner till den enda svenskspråkiga sajt där fri diskussion om "Förintelsen" tillåts. Och dessa herrar, Tinnitus etc., har gjort det i åratal nu...:
http://www.vho.org/tr/2004/1/Graf97-101.html
Citat:
"---In short: The official Treblinka version is an uninterrupted chain of absurdities. .This, however, does not answer the question of the camp’s actual purpose. Such revisionists as Arthur Butz, Robert Faurisson, Mark Weber, and Andrew Allen hypothesized that Treblinka was a transfer camp many years ago. Mattogno meticulously sets forth, on the basis of numerous documents, the National Socialist policy of Jewish resettlement to the East in two chapters, and in the final chapter provides evidence upon evidence and proof upon proof that those Jews who were brought to Treblinka were indeed subsequently sent through to other destinations. In order to counter the objection that, in the end, it does not matter whether the Jews were gassed in Poland or shot farther east, Mattogno in another chapter scrutinizes the thesis of the orthodox historians, according to which the Einsatzgruppen performed a policy of systematic extermination of Jews in the occupied eastern territories, and demonstrates that this allegation is untenable.
That Treblinka served, among other things, as a transit camp to Majdanek and other work camps in the Lublin area is admitted even by the Jewish historians Tatiana Berenstein and Adam Rutkowski. In the verdict of the Demjanjuk trial in Jerusalem certain former Jewish deportees were named who arrived in Majdanek after a short stay in Treblinka. It is more difficult to prove that Jews were deported from Treblinka to the occupied Soviet areas, but at least one solidly documented proof exists. On July 31, 1942, one week after the opening of Treblinka, the Reichskommissar for White Russia, Wilhelm Kube, excitedly objected to Reichskomissar for the Eastern territories Heinrich Lohse against the transportation of 1,000 Jews from Warsaw to Minsk, on the grounds that these Jews represented a danger as potential carriers of epidemics and as supporters of the partisans. At that time all deported Jews from Warsaw arrived in Treblinka, so that those 1,000 Jews must have been sent through that camp to Minsk. This one transport already is enough to shake the foundations of the story of the "pure extermination camp," in which every Jew except for a handful of "work Jews" was immediately murdered. Whoever objects that this transport is merely an exception must ask himeself how many other such "exceptions" existed.
Of course much is still obscure: the exact number of Jews deported to Treblinka, the exact destinations of those who were transferred from there, the fate of those who survived the harsh conditions of the war. There is reason to hope that the improving accessibility to the archives in the new nations that have sprung from the former USSR will make it possible for historians who are interested in the truth to shed more and more light into this darkness.---"
That Treblinka served, among other things, as a transit camp to Majdanek and other work camps in the Lublin area is admitted even by the Jewish historians Tatiana Berenstein and Adam Rutkowski. In the verdict of the Demjanjuk trial in Jerusalem certain former Jewish deportees were named who arrived in Majdanek after a short stay in Treblinka. It is more difficult to prove that Jews were deported from Treblinka to the occupied Soviet areas, but at least one solidly documented proof exists. On July 31, 1942, one week after the opening of Treblinka, the Reichskommissar for White Russia, Wilhelm Kube, excitedly objected to Reichskomissar for the Eastern territories Heinrich Lohse against the transportation of 1,000 Jews from Warsaw to Minsk, on the grounds that these Jews represented a danger as potential carriers of epidemics and as supporters of the partisans. At that time all deported Jews from Warsaw arrived in Treblinka, so that those 1,000 Jews must have been sent through that camp to Minsk. This one transport already is enough to shake the foundations of the story of the "pure extermination camp," in which every Jew except for a handful of "work Jews" was immediately murdered. Whoever objects that this transport is merely an exception must ask himeself how many other such "exceptions" existed.
Of course much is still obscure: the exact number of Jews deported to Treblinka, the exact destinations of those who were transferred from there, the fate of those who survived the harsh conditions of the war. There is reason to hope that the improving accessibility to the archives in the new nations that have sprung from the former USSR will make it possible for historians who are interested in the truth to shed more and more light into this darkness.---"

Breendonk var dock aldrig något stort läger, inte heller byggt för förintelse.